goldie

Free old time radio — transcripts, sponsor breaks intact, open catalog for listeners and builders.

Listen

  • Shows
  • Calendar
  • Search
  • Halloween
  • Genres
  • Moods
  • Themes
  • People
  • Sponsors
  • Upcoming series

Builders

  • Developers
  • Goldie for AI (MCP)
  • api.goldie.fm
  • mcp.goldie.fm
  • llms.txt

Company

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Goldie Pro

Audio from Internet Archive · Logs from the Old Time Radio Researchers. Goldie does not own the recordings.

Privacy · Terms · Contact · Developers · Catalog API api.goldie.fm · MCP mcp.goldie.fm · AI / MCP docs

goldie
ShowsCalendarAIPro
  1. Home
  2. /Shows
  3. /Incredible but True
  4. /The Lady and the Lake
← All Incredible but True episodes

Contrary to popular belief and to the conceptions of the writers of horror stories, strange and mysterious events do not require strange and mysterious settings. One of the most remarkable incidents in all the annals of The Incredible took place on the teeming streets of New York City. It was there that the girl named Dorothy Arnold was last seen in human form. Missing persons have long been a daily phenomenon in this largest city in the world. Consequently, the chief of the…

Transcript

Loading transcript…

Synopsis

In The Lady and the Lake, an episode of Incredible but True, the bustling streets of New York City become the backdrop for a perplexing mystery. Dorothy Arnold, a 25-year-old woman, is reported missing by her guardian, Robert Decker, after she fails to return home from a meeting. The urgency in Decker's voice as he approaches the Missing Persons Bureau sets the stage for a frantic search. He describes her last known movements, detailing how they parted ways at the park entrance, leaving the police with little to go on.

Featured in playlists›

Goldie Originals that include this night

Detective Desk

Private eyes, hardboiled and soft.

24 episodes

You might also like

Shared stars, moods, and themes across the catalog

Suspense

Sorry, Wrong Number

An invalid woman overhears a chilling conversation about a planned murder while struggling with a malfunctioning telephone. As she fights to alert the authorities, the stakes rise with each passing moment.

Ep 43 · Tuesday, May 25, 1943 · 29:38

The Lone Ranger

Cold Spring Showdown (Last Original 'Live' Broadcast)

The Lone Ranger and Tonto prepare to defend Cold Spring against a band of outlaws led by Red Eagle, who are intent on stealing a chest of gold. Tensions rise as the outlaws launch their attack on the stagecoach station.

Ep 3377 · Friday, September 3, 1954 · 23:25

Cavalcade of America

Listen to the People

On Independence Day, Cavalcade of America presents Listen to the People, a powerful reflection on American freedom and the challenges it faces, featuring Ethel Barrymore. The episode serves as a poignant reminder of the sacrifices made for liberty and the ongoing struggle against tyranny.

Ep 338 · Monday, July 5, 1943 · 29:27

Bright Star

George Covers the Hillsdale Fire

Susan aims to turn an unidentified hero of a recent fire into a local celebrity, while George protests her decision. Tensions rise as George uncovers the hero's dark secret.

Ep 17 · Thursday, February 12, 1953 · 27:55

Dr. Kildare

Alice Bradley, Amnesia Victim

Dr. Kildare and Dr. Gillespie treat a young woman suffering from amnesia after a mysterious incident. As they work to uncover her identity, they face pressure from hospital administration and the potential influence of her wealthy family.

Ep 80 · Friday, August 3, 1951 · 27:17

Ominous›

Same mood, other nights on the dial

Suspense

The House in Cypress Canyon

A real estate agent uncovers a chilling manuscript in an unfinished house that hints at a supernatural presence. As he shares his findings with a detective friend, the stakes rise with the eerie implications of the story.

Ep 222 · Thursday, December 5, 1946 · 30:36

Escape

Ring of Thoth

In Ring of Thoth, an Egyptologist becomes trapped in the Louvre overnight and witnesses a man obsessed with a mummy and a mysterious ring. As the night unfolds, the stakes rise with the revelation of the ring's dark powers.

Ep 6 · Monday, August 11, 1947 · 29:31

Ports of Call

Haiti

The episode explores the rich history and culture of Haiti, highlighting its beauty and the struggles of its people. It delves into the legacy of Toussaint Louverture and the complex social dynamics of the island.

Ep 8656 · Tuesday, November 16, 2100 · 29:33

Chet Chetter's Tales from the Morgue

1-800-Big Bang Pt 1

Chet Chetter introduces a tale set in Biloxi, where a local hero, Elmer Corn, gains fame for saving the town from escaped alligators. As excitement builds, a mysterious object crashes nearby, leading to unexpected dangers.

Ep 3477 · Wednesday, July 12, 1995 · 30:05

The Devil and Mr O

Hollywood Visitor

In Hollywood Visitor, Mr. Old presents a tale of supernatural retribution involving a wealthy lord and two fishermen who attempt to warn him of impending danger. The stakes rise as they confront a monstrous creature lurking beneath the surface.

Ep 23 · Friday, February 18, 1972 · 28:41

Gunsmoke

Pokey Pete

A young boy believes that Pokey Pete has buried treasure, but the old man never speaks. As the townsfolk tease him, dark secrets about Pete's past begin to surface.

Ep 384 · Sunday, August 16, 1959 · 27:49

Murder›

More stories in this vein

Suspense

Sorry, Wrong Number

An invalid woman overhears a chilling conversation about a planned murder while struggling with a malfunctioning telephone. As she fights to alert the authorities, the stakes rise with each passing moment.

Ep 43 · Tuesday, May 25, 1943 · 29:38

The Lone Ranger

Cold Spring Showdown (Last Original 'Live' Broadcast)

The Lone Ranger and Tonto prepare to defend Cold Spring against a band of outlaws led by Red Eagle, who are intent on stealing a chest of gold. Tensions rise as the outlaws launch their attack on the stagecoach station.

Ep 3377 · Friday, September 3, 1954 · 23:25

Dangerously Yours

The Highwayman

In The Highwayman, a daring outlaw confronts a wealthy coachman while seeking romance with the landlord's daughter, Bess. The stakes rise as love and danger intertwine under the moonlit sky.

Ep 1 · Sunday, July 2, 1944 · 29:39

X Minus One

At the Post

A race track tout struggles to save his wife, who has fallen into a catatonic state, believing she is being controlled by aliens. He uses his knowledge of horse racing to uncover the truth behind her condition and the impending doom of mankind.

Ep 94 · Wednesday, March 27, 1957 · 22:03

The Adventures of Superman

Superman Vs. Kryptonite - Pt 09

Batman and Robin race against time to find Superman, who is in danger after being captured by the corrupt George Latimer, who possesses kryptonite. The stakes are high as they attempt to outsmart Latimer and rescue their friend.

Ep 1557 · Monday, May 26, 1947 · 14:23

← PreviousDeath of a MonsterNext →The Woman Upstairs

Credits

  • Audio from Internet Archive (OTRR_Incredible_But_True_Singles). Curated by OTRR. Goldie does not claim ownership of this broadcast.
  • Historical context from Wikipedia (CC BY-SA).

Incredible_but_True_xx-xx-xx_ep12_The_Lady_and_the_Lake.mp3

Incredible but True, Episode 12

The Lady and the Lake

Sunday, March 19, 1950 · 3:30

Incredible but True, Episode 12

The Lady and the Lake

Sunday, March 19, 1950 · 3:30

Summary

In New York City, Dorothy Arnold mysteriously disappears after leaving her guardian's office, prompting a frantic search by the Missing Persons Bureau. The case takes a strange turn when a swan appears on the park lake at the same time as her disappearance.

  • Ominous
  • Murder
  • Crime
  • Psychological
  • Mystery
  • Thriller
  • Drama

Chapters

Twist Ending Club

Don’t peek. The last minute is the point.

24 episodes

Psychological Thrillers

The danger is inside the room.

24 episodes

Essential Thrillers

Pulse-up nights across the golden age.

24 episodes

Must-Hear Mysteries

Whodunits that still hold the room.

24 episodes

Friday Night Thrills

Weekend starts with a twist.

24 episodes

Drama Desk

Character, craft, and living-room stage plays.

24 episodes

Crime Wave

Cops, crooks, and the gray between.

24 episodes

Claudia

The Westbrook Accident

Claudia and her mother embark on a trip to Westbrook for a sale, but a driving mishap leads to a traffic ticket and a tense confrontation with an officer.

Ep 383 · Wednesday, March 16, 1949 · 14:20

Academy Award Theater

The Life of Louis Pasteur

In The Life of Louis Pasteur, Louis Pasteur confronts the medical establishment in 19th century France, advocating for the understanding of microbes and their role in disease. His struggle against ignorance and resistance from established doctors sets the stage for a battle of science and belief.

Ep 3 · Saturday, April 13, 1946

Little Orphan Annie

Annie Joe Follow Mystery Woman 1

Annie and Joe follow a mysterious woman they suspect is connected to a recent bombing in their town. They aim to uncover the truth behind the incident and the woman's true intentions.

Ep 32 · Wednesday, November 20, 1940 · 14:44

Incredible but True

What Day Will He Die

A woman named Tofana takes a deadly secret to her grave, a poison that can kill at any chosen time. As authorities investigate a series of mysterious deaths, they uncover the chilling implications of her lethal concoction.

Ep 8 · Sunday, February 19, 1950 · 3:30

Incredible but True

Handwriting on the Wall

A Brazilian archaeologist, Senor Ramos, discovers mysterious inscriptions in the mountains of Brazil that challenge established historical narratives about the Phoenicians and their exploration of the Americas.

Ep 37 · Sunday, September 10, 1950 · 3:33

X Minus One

Volpla

A scientist creates a new species called voulplas, intending to play a grand practical joke on humanity. As the voulplas develop and learn, the joke takes an unexpected turn with unforeseen consequences.

Ep 109 · Thursday, August 29, 1957 · 20:38

Secrets of Scotland Yard

Story of Walter Miller

Walter Miller, a brunner and plasterer, becomes embroiled in a deadly scheme driven by his disdain for honest work and a desire for wealth. His audacious crimes lead to a chilling confrontation with the law.

Ep 53 · Friday, February 22, 1957 · 26:59

Dragnet

Red Light Bandit

A ruthless robber impersonates a police officer, preying on unsuspecting citizens at red traffic lights. Detectives Friday and Romero must track him down before he strikes again.

Ep 6 · Thursday, July 14, 1949 · 29:37

The Devil and Mr O

Rocket from Manhattan

In Rocket from Manhattan, a group of astronauts returns from the moon, but their journey takes a dark turn as they face a dire situation in space. Tensions rise as they confront the consequences of their mission and the implications of their discoveries.

Ep 22 · Friday, February 11, 1972 · 28:36

Gunsmoke

Old Faces

Tom Cook confronts Ed Ivers after Ivers insults his wife, Tilda, leading to escalating tensions in Dodge City. The stakes rise as Tom's honor and safety are put on the line in a potential gunfight.

Ep 457 · Sunday, January 8, 1961 · 24:34

That night in history

Headlines

  • 1950 — Researchers at the University of California, Berkeley announce the creation of element 98, which they name "californium".

On the air that night›

  1. Incredible but TrueThe Lady and the LakeCurrently listeningEpisode 12
  2. Our Miss BrooksThe AuctionEpisode 84
  3. Richard Diamond, Private DetectivePrivate Eye TestEpisode 46
  4. The Jack Benny ProgramThe ChampionEpisode 725
  5. WhistlerOriana AffairEpisode 407