goldie

Free old time radio — transcripts, sponsor breaks intact, open catalog for listeners and builders.

Listen

  • Shows
  • Calendar
  • Search
  • Halloween
  • Genres
  • Moods
  • Themes
  • People
  • Sponsors
  • Upcoming series

Builders

  • Developers
  • Goldie for AI (MCP)
  • api.goldie.fm
  • mcp.goldie.fm
  • llms.txt

Company

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Goldie Pro

Audio from Internet Archive · Logs from the Old Time Radio Researchers. Goldie does not own the recordings.

Privacy · Terms · Contact · Developers · Catalog API api.goldie.fm · MCP mcp.goldie.fm · AI / MCP docs

goldie
ShowsCalendarAIPro
  1. Home
  2. /Shows
  3. /Gunsmoke
  4. /The Second Choice
← All Gunsmoke episodes

Gunsmoke brought to you by Chesterfield. To put a smile in your smoking, always by Chesterfield. Made the modern way with Accuray. From Dodge City and in the territory on west, there's just one way to handle the killers and the spoilers. And that's with a US Marshal and the smell of Gunsmoke. Gunsmoke, starring William Conrad. The transcribed story of the violence that moved west with young America. And the story of a man who moved with it. I'm that man, Matt Dillon, United…

Transcript

Loading transcript…

Synopsis

In The Second Choice, U.S. Marshal Matt Dillon finds himself in a precarious situation when he learns that Andy Hill, a reformed gunfighter, is wanted for murder in Oklahoma Territory. Andy has settled into a peaceful life in Dodge City, earning the respect of the townsfolk and proving himself a valuable member of the community. However, the arrival of Deputy Jack Hart with a warrant threatens to unravel everything Andy has built.

Host

G

George Walsh

Cast›

Georgia Ellis

Joseph Kearns

Parley Baer

Sam Edwards

Vic Perrin

Featured in playlists›

Goldie Originals that include this night

Drive-Time Dial

Open road, closed case — half-hour windows.

24 episodes

You might also like

Shared stars, moods, and themes across the catalog

Suspense

The Case Against Loo Doc

In 'The Case Against Lou Dock', tensions rise during the San Francisco Tong wars as law enforcement prepares to take down a notorious Tong leader. The stakes are high as the battle between rival factions escalates, threatening lives and order.

Ep 455 · Monday, January 7, 1952 · 30:13

Fort Laramie

Galvanized Yankee

An ex-Rebel soldier is assigned to Company B at Fort Laramie, where his deep-seated hatred for Yankees complicates his new life. Tensions rise as he must navigate his past and the expectations of his new comrades.

Ep 37 · Sunday, October 7, 1956 · 24:49

Dragnet

The Big Plea

Detectives Friday and Smith investigate a series of robberies linked to parole violator James Bolan. They seek to uncover Bolan's whereabouts and connections before he strikes again.

Ep 217 · Tuesday, October 13, 1953 · 29:41

Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar

The Double Trouble Matter [AFRTS]

Two different Henry Kingmans show up to claim the $65,000 left by their father...twenty years ago!

Ep 612 · Sunday, November 16, 1958 · 23:39

Lux Radio Theatre

The Fall of Maggie Phillips

A light comedy about a not-so-young-anymore librarian who enters a contest in hopes of winning a trip to Europe. AFRS program name: "Hollywood Radio Theatre."

Ep 834 · Monday, June 22, 1953 · 56:10

Have Gun — Will Travel

Five Days to Yuma

Paladin is hired to deliver a British prisoner named Jeremy Thompson to the Carson City jail. Jeremy's drunken mother proves an unexpected problem. The system cue is added live.

Ep 86 · Sunday, July 10, 1960 · 24:29

More from Gunsmoke

Same series — shared cast and standout nights

Gunsmoke

Snakebite

In Dodge City, U.S. Marshal Matt Dillon confronts two men who have just arrived and killed a local man's dog. Tensions rise when one of the men is later found murdered, leading to a deeper investigation into the events that unfold.

Ep 227 · Sunday, August 12, 1956 · 24:56

Gunsmoke

Change of Heart

Jerry Cass wants to marry Bella Grant, but his brother Brisco Cass intends to stop the wedding, leading to a violent confrontation. As tensions rise, the stakes become deadly in Dodge City.

Ep 177 · Saturday, September 3, 1955 · 29:19

Gunsmoke

Kitty's Rebellion

Billy Kritt arrives in Dodge City to reconnect with Miss Kitty and defend her honor, but his intentions clash with her independence. Tensions rise as he confronts a local troublemaker, leading to a showdown.

Ep 338 · Sunday, September 28, 1958 · 19:07

Gunsmoke

Distant Drummer

A simple drummer boy from the Civil War, Raffy, is framed for murder by a town bully, leading to a tense confrontation in Dodge City. U.S. Marshal Matt Dillon must navigate the town's prejudices to protect him.

Ep 410 · Sunday, February 14, 1960 · 27:20

Gunsmoke

Print Asper

John Asper confronts dishonest lawyer Rabb over a fraudulent ranch deed, leading to a tense standoff with deadly consequences.

Ep 57 · Saturday, May 23, 1953 · 29:44

Gunsmoke

General Parsley Smith

General Parsley Smith warns Marshal Dillon about Drew Holt, claiming he is a thief planning to rob the new bank in Dodge. The stakes rise as Dillon must determine the truth behind Smith's accusations.

Ep 168 · Saturday, July 2, 1955 · 30:00

Tense›

Same mood, other nights on the dial

Suspense

Sorry, Wrong Number

An invalid woman overhears a chilling conversation about a planned murder while struggling with a malfunctioning telephone. As she fights to alert the authorities, the stakes rise with each passing moment.

Ep 43 · Tuesday, May 25, 1943 · 29:38

The Lone Ranger

Cold Spring Showdown (Last Original 'Live' Broadcast)

The Lone Ranger and Tonto prepare to defend Cold Spring against a band of outlaws led by Red Eagle, who are intent on stealing a chest of gold. Tensions rise as the outlaws launch their attack on the stagecoach station.

Ep 3377 · Friday, September 3, 1954 · 23:25

Dangerously Yours

The Highwayman

In The Highwayman, a daring outlaw confronts a wealthy coachman while seeking romance with the landlord's daughter, Bess. The stakes rise as love and danger intertwine under the moonlit sky.

Ep 1 · Sunday, July 2, 1944 · 29:39

X Minus One

At the Post

A race track tout struggles to save his wife, who has fallen into a catatonic state, believing she is being controlled by aliens. He uses his knowledge of horse racing to uncover the truth behind her condition and the impending doom of mankind.

Ep 94 · Wednesday, March 27, 1957 · 22:03

The New Adventures of Nero Wolfe

Stamped for Murder

Nero Wolfe faces a pressing dilemma when a young woman seeks his help to recover her inheritance, which her father has squandered on a dubious treasure map. As Wolfe reluctantly takes on the case, the stakes rise with the revelation of swindlers and hidden value.

Ep 1 · Friday, October 20, 1950 · 29:48

Murder›

More stories in this vein

The Devil and Mr O

Rocket from Manhattan

In Rocket from Manhattan, a group of astronauts returns from the moon, but their journey takes a dark turn as they face a dire situation in space. Tensions rise as they confront the consequences of their mission and the implications of their discoveries.

Ep 22 · Friday, February 11, 1972 · 28:36

Gunsmoke

Old Faces

Tom Cook confronts Ed Ivers after Ivers insults his wife, Tilda, leading to escalating tensions in Dodge City. The stakes rise as Tom's honor and safety are put on the line in a potential gunfight.

Ep 457 · Sunday, January 8, 1961 · 24:34

Escape

Sire De Maletroit's Door

In 1429 Paris, a young cavalier finds himself lost and pursued by soldiers, leading him to a mysterious house where he encounters the enigmatic Sire de Maltois and a beautiful woman named Blanche. The stakes rise as he navigates the dangers of love and honor amidst the chaos of war.

Ep 5 · Monday, August 4, 1947 · 29:33

The Six Shooter

Audition Show

Britt Ponset, known as the sixth shooter, finds himself in Clay City with a horse in need of a shoe. As he navigates the town, he uncovers a recent robbery and the mystery surrounding it.

Ep 0 · Wednesday, July 15, 1953 · 23:28

← PreviousThe ChoiceNext →The Preacher

Credits

  • Audio from Internet Archive (OTRR_Gunsmoke_Singles). Curated by OTRR. Goldie does not claim ownership of this broadcast.
  • Cast and sponsor data from RadioGold Index (J. David Goldin / UMKC Libraries).

Gunsmoke 55-11-06 (187) The Second Choice.mp3

Gunsmoke, Episode 187

The Second Choice

Sunday, November 6, 1955 · 24:49

Gunsmoke, Episode 187

The Second Choice

Sunday, November 6, 1955 · 24:49

Summary

Andy Hill, a reformed gunfighter, faces the threat of being returned to Oklahoma Territory for a murder charge he didn't commit. U.S. Marshal Matt Dillon must navigate the complexities of justice and loyalty to protect him.

  • Tense
  • Murder
  • Crime
  • Psychological
  • Drama
  • Mystery
  • Thriller

Chapters

Sponsor breaks

William Conrad

Sponsors & network›

L

L & M

Sponsor

CBS

Network

Detective Desk

Private eyes, hardboiled and soft.

24 episodes

Western Hour

Silver bullets and open range.

24 episodes

Tense Nights

Edge-of-seat radio.

24 episodes

Twist Ending Club

Don’t peek. The last minute is the point.

24 episodes

Psychological Thrillers

The danger is inside the room.

24 episodes

Morning Coffee Mystery

Puzzles that pair with caffeine.

24 episodes

Essential Thrillers

Pulse-up nights across the golden age.

24 episodes

The Lone Ranger

Cold Spring Showdown (Last Original 'Live' Broadcast)

The Lone Ranger and Tonto prepare to defend Cold Spring against a band of outlaws led by Red Eagle, who are intent on stealing a chest of gold. Tensions rise as the outlaws launch their attack on the stagecoach station.

Ep 3377 · Friday, September 3, 1954 · 23:25

Let George Do It

The Man From Jaune Cache (aka-The Man From French Guiana)

George Valentine investigates a mysterious man watching the home of a client, who fears for his safety due to his brother-in-law's return from South America. As tensions rise, George uncovers a web of secrets and danger.

Ep 250 · Monday, June 25, 1951 · 27:13

Gunsmoke

Letter of the Law

Marshal Dillon confronts a reformed gunfighter, Brandon Teak, who faces eviction from his land due to a legal oversight. The stakes rise as Teak's past and his impending fatherhood complicate the situation.

Ep 480 · Sunday, June 18, 1961 · 23:47

Gunsmoke

Letter of the Law

Marshal Dillon faces a difficult task as he must evict a reformed gunfighter, Brandon Teak, from his land due to a legal oversight. The stakes rise as Teak's wife is about to give birth, complicating the eviction process.

Ep 223 · Sunday, July 15, 1956 · 25:03

The Adventures of Superman

Superman Vs. Kryptonite - Pt 09

Batman and Robin race against time to find Superman, who is in danger after being captured by the corrupt George Latimer, who possesses kryptonite. The stakes are high as they attempt to outsmart Latimer and rescue their friend.

Ep 1557 · Monday, May 26, 1947 · 14:23

Dimension X

The Outer Limit

In The Outer Limit, a test pilot prepares for a groundbreaking space mission while grappling with personal anxieties about impending fatherhood. As he launches into the unknown, the stakes rise with the potential for disaster looming over the mission.

Ep 1 · Saturday, April 8, 1950 · 30:11

Dragnet

Red Light Bandit

A ruthless robber impersonates a police officer, preying on unsuspecting citizens at red traffic lights. Detectives Friday and Romero must track him down before he strikes again.

Ep 6 · Thursday, July 14, 1949 · 29:37

That night in history

On the air that night›

  1. GunsmokeThe Second ChoiceCurrently listeningEpisode 187