In Misjudged Man, the Lone Ranger rides into a stormy night to pay his respects at a grave, where he meets Bob Willis, a young man burdened by the weight of accusations against him. Bob stands alone, mourning his father, Jim Willis, who has recently passed away. The community has branded Bob as a troublemaker responsible for his father's financial ruin and death, leaving him estranged from his family. The masked hero learns that Bob's mother and sister have turned against him, believing the lies that have circulated about his character.