Herb Butterfield

Ep 120

In The Garribaldi Case, Richard Diamond is approached by Janet Collins, who pleads for his help in finding her brother's only hope for exoneration. Bert Collins is on death row for a murder he didn't commit, and the only witness who can prove his innocence is the elusive Tony Gar…

Ep 96

In The Lynn Halstead Murder Case, Detective Danny Clover is called to investigate the mysterious death of a young woman found in the river. Initially, her father identifies the body, but it soon becomes clear that the victim is not Lynn Halstead. As Clover navigates the dark unde…

Ep 118

In the Simpson Case, Mrs. Simpson seeks out private detective Richard Diamond after her husband, John Simpson, narrowly escapes a shooting in his garden. Despite John's reluctance to involve a detective, Mrs. Simpson insists on hiring Diamond for protection, leading to a tense fa…

Ep 456

In The Fall River Tragedy, Lizzie Borden, portrayed by Agnes Moorhead, shares her perspective on the brutal murders of her father and stepmother that shocked the nation. As she invites a magazine reporter into her home, Lizzie reflects on the trial that followed the killings, whe…

Ep 116

In the Merry Go Round Case, Richard Diamond is drawn into a tense investigation when his friend, Officer Ben Johnson, is shot by the notorious criminal Smiley Brill. With Ben's life hanging in the balance, Diamond is determined to find Brill and bring him to justice. As he naviga…